Welcome to The Alumni Club Tavern & Eatery, a beloved gem nestled in the heart of Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin. Located at N88 W16718 Appleton Ave, this inviting establishment offers a perfect blend of hearty meals and friendly service, making it a go-to destination for both locals and visitors alike.

The moment you step inside, you notice a warm and welcoming atmosphere. The exceptional staff greets you with genuine smiles, ready to cater to your dining needs. Here, patrons rave about the outstanding service, with many guests like Susan Haugland recalling delightful meals and a welcoming vibe. Whether you’re looking for a casual lunch or a lively dinner, The Alumni Club is the place to be.

The menu boasts a variety of mouth-watering options that cater to all tastes. For those with a penchant for fresh greens, the Spinach Salad is a must-try, featuring crisp leaf spinach, boiled eggs, and a delicious mix of toppings including bacon. If you prefer something heartier, the Loaded Grilled Cheese captures that nostalgic comfort food essence, piled high with creamy American and Cheddar cheeses, tomato, and the delightful crunch of maple bacon on thick Texas toast. Additionally, the Chicken Sandwich and Steak Sandwich promise to leave you satisfied with their tender meats and robust flavors.

On popular occasions such as Friday Fish Fry, The Alumni Club Tavern & Eatery really comes alive. Valeria C. notes the exciting specials that draw a crowd, but fear not if the main dining area fills up; there’s an overflow room downstairs to accommodate all guests. Tina Schmidt’s rave about the Irish Benedict during a Mother’s Day brunch showcases the eatery's versatility and commitment to delightful culinary experiences.

The drink menu further enhances the dining experience, offering a variety of options perfect for pairing with the food. Guests can unwind with a cold Schlitz or enjoy a perfectly crafted Bloody Mary—Tina certainly found them “delicious”—while sharing laughs with friends and family.

For a more casual outing, there's the friendly bar scene where you can enjoy the unique Wisconsin Pizza Fries, a fan favorite among regulars like Wisconny Johnny. The communal environment, punctuated by laughter and engaging conversations, adds a layer of excitement to your visit.

The Alumni Club Tavern & Eatery stands as a testament to what a community eatery should be—inviting, engaging, and brimming with flavorful dishes that keep patrons coming back for more. Whether you’re after a cozy meal or a social night out, this establishment caters to both ends, ensuring your time spent here is memorable. Don’t forget to indulge in their delectable soup of the day, perfectly paired with buttered Italian bread to warm you up on a chilly day. Make your way to The Alumni Club, where great food, friendly faces, and a delightful atmosphere await!